Laptop displaying a control chart with plotted points and limit lines in a workshop office
Operations Management · PART FIVE

Statistical Process Control

Common versus assignable variation, control charts for means, ranges, and proportions, plus Pareto analysis and process capability.

Variation

Common (natural) variation
The ordinary random variation built into a stable process. It is reduced only by changing the process itself.
Assignable (special) variation
Variation with a findable cause — a worn tool, a new material lot, an untrained operator. It is removed by fixing that cause.
In control
Only common variation is present; the process is predictable — which is not the same as acceptable.
Out of control
A point beyond a control limit, or a non-random pattern such as a run, trend, or cycle.

Control charts plot sample statistics over time against a centerline and control limits set three standard deviations either side. Variables charts measure something (length, weight, minutes); attributes charts count something (defective or not, number of defects).

Charts for variables: x̄ and R

Formula

x̄ chart: centerline = x̄̄, UCL = x̄̄ + A₂R̄, LCL = x̄̄ − A₂R̄R chart: centerline = R̄, UCL = D₄R̄, LCL = D₃R̄
Control chart factors by sample size n
nA₂D₃D₄
21.88003.267
31.02302.575
40.72902.282
50.57702.115
60.48302.004
70.4190.0761.924
80.3730.1361.864
90.3370.1841.816
100.3080.2231.777
120.2660.2831.717
150.2230.3471.653

Worked example

Worked example: mean and range charts

A filling line is sampled five times, four bottles per sample. Target fill is 10.0 ounces.

Sample data (ounces)
SampleObs 1Obs 2Obs 3Obs 4Mean x̄Range R
110.210.09.810.010.000.4
210.110.39.910.110.100.4
39.910.010.29.910.000.3
410.310.210.010.310.200.3
59.810.09.910.310.000.5

Formula

x̄̄ = 50.30 ÷ 5 = 10.06 oz R̄ = 1.9 ÷ 5 = 0.38 ozn = 4, so A₂ = 0.729, D₃ = 0, D₄ = 2.282x̄ chart: UCL = 10.06 + 0.729(0.38) = 10.34 LCL = 10.06 − 0.277 = 9.78R chart: UCL = 2.282(0.38) = 0.87 LCL = 0(0.38) = 0

Every sample mean falls between 9.78 and 10.34, and every range falls below 0.87, so the process is in control. Note that the process is centered at 10.06 rather than 10.0 — being in control does not mean being on target.

Charts for attributes: the p-chart

Formula

p̄ = total defectives ÷ total units inspectedσp = √[ p̄(1 − p̄) ÷ n ]UCL = p̄ + 3σp LCL = p̄ − 3σp (use 0 if negative)

Worked example

Worked example: proportion defective

Ten samples of 100 finished orders are audited for errors.

Sample12345678910
Defectives3241523424

Formula

Total defectives = 30, total inspected = 1,000, so p̄ = 0.03σp = √[0.03(0.97) ÷ 100] = √0.000291 = 0.0171UCL = 0.03 + 3(0.0171) = 0.081 LCL = 0.03 − 0.051 → 0

The highest sample proportion is 0.05, inside the upper limit, so the error rate is stable at about 3%. Reducing it below 3% requires changing the process, not chasing individual samples.

Pareto analysis

Pareto analysis ranks causes by frequency or cost so effort goes where the payoff is. Typically a small share of causes produces most of the problem.

Customer complaints, one quarter
ComplaintCountPercentCumulative
Late delivery8050%50%
Wrong item shipped4025%75%
Damaged packaging2012.5%87.5%
Billing error127.5%95%
Other85%100%
Total160100%

Fixing late delivery and mis-shipments addresses three-quarters of all complaints.

Process capability

Control limits describe what the process does; specification limits describe what the customer requires. Capability compares the two.

Formula

Cp = (Upper spec − Lower spec) ÷ 6σCpk = minimum of [ (Upper spec − μ) ÷ 3σ , (μ − Lower spec) ÷ 3σ ]Cp or Cpk of 1.00 means the process just fills the tolerance; 1.33 or more is the common target.

Guide: Operations Management

NEXT · PART SIX: Supply Chain and Facilities

Continue the guide

Need help applying this?

Baltimore resource partners offer free coaching on operations, quality, purchasing, and inventory for small businesses.